Beckilina

Sunday, October 26, 2008

One of my censored articles

TWO birdlike women cling together as though they hope to bind their
tiny frames and dark skin to each other. They are mother and daughter.
Between them they clasp a plastic bag of neatly folded, well-worn
longyi -a typical Burmese skirt.

We are stood in front of the grill of a pawnshop in North Okkala, a
township in Yangon division. A few sewing machines hang quiescence
from hooks along the walls, like carcasses strung up at an abattoir.
Jiffy cans, metal spoons and piles of old clothes are wrapped up in
newspaper and arranged in precarious piles that cascade onto the
floor; the shop is literally overflowing.

"We only come when it is an emergency," the younger woman tells me.
Though it soon becomes clear that it is an emergency every couple of
days now.

Their house was never strong, the women tell me, so, when on May 2 190
kilometre winds ripped through this neighbourhood, it collapsed like a
house of cards. They can't afford to rebuild and so now live squeezed
into their relatives' house. "We need the money," the mother says, "It
has got so much harder since Nargis. We bring our clothes here every
few days now." Her smile hides more than it reveals.

The Ayeyarwady delta bore the brunt of Cyclone Nargis, but even in
Yangon where things have been quicker to recover, local people have
used up their savings to repair damaged property and cover burgeoning
prices. With a financial system that can only be described as
dysfunctional almost no one in the country has a bank account or is
eligible for a loan. Fifty percent of the population had some kind of
debt before the cyclone. Now, not only are survivors unable to pay
back existing loans but for the people like those waiting in line
outside of pawnshops in North Okkala, recovery efforts have required a
plunge into further debt.

In exchange for the clothes they receive a loan of 500 kyat (fifty
cents), with a monthly interest rate of ten percent. They will use the
money to buy vegetables that they cook and sell to shops. If they are
lucky in a few days they can buy back their clothes. If not, after
three months, just like their house, they will lose the clothes.

This hand to mouth existence is made worse by the debt that now hangs
over their head. After the cyclone a neighbour lent them money, "they
felt sympathy for us," the mother explains, "But the interest rate is
double [what it was previous to Nargis]. We borrowed 30,000 kyat at
9000 kyat [interest rate] every ten days."

Some people in this area now share pots and plates with their
neighbours, while their crockery sits held hostage amongst the growing
piles in the pawnshops. The items are more an incentive for quick
payback than intrinsically valuable. Just as congealed blood tells of
the wound beneath, so the old clothes and cooking utensils are
desperate moments condensed into solid form.

The stories are unremitting: There is the retired government nurse,
living off her pension of 2000 kyat (US$2) a month. She has broken her
arm and four months since the cyclone still cannot afford to fix her
destroyed roof. Another woman had never visited a pawnshop before
Nargis, but has now sold everything to repair her home, she is here
today with her final form of saving – a gold ring. Another woman
grasps an exceptional item – a DVD player. Only about five percent of
households in this neighbourhood even possess a radio according to a
UNDP Poverty Profile 2007 report. It is a sign that Cyclone Nargis has
left a trail not just in the homes of the poor but also amongst the
relatively middle class.

"People don't have much savings to begin with but because there is
rightly a mistrust of the banks," says Dr Sean Turnell, of Burma
Economic Watch and Associate Professor at Macquarie University,
Australia via email. "Most people store whatever surplus they have in
a 'physical' form (extra supplies, sometimes precious stones, gold,
cash etc). Much of this was destroyed in the cyclone,"

"People have three options [for borrowing money]," says Khin Maung
Nyo, head of the World Economic Journal based in Yangon, "you pawn
something which is permitted in shops with licenses with SPDC, or you
go to an moneylender. Finally there are also overnight money lenders,
with a ten percent daily rate."

The dependence on loans as a form of survival is echoed in the
government's chief form of assistance to farmers in the delta. Rather
than offering grants, as recommended by disaster relief experts, the
Myanmar agricultural Development Bank (MADB) has expanded a loan
scheme from K7 to K9 billion countrywide, which has provided seeds and
machinery to farmers affected by the cyclone. 85 percent of loans in
the delta are for machinery, which must be paid for at a 17 percent
interest rate within three years. Seedlings and livestock are offered
at a 3-4percent interest rate.

The MADB is not without controversies.

"The Myanmar Agricultural Development Bank should have a big role in
reconstruction in the delta," says Sean Turnell, "Instead, it is
essentially a moribund institution that has been rapidly
'decapitalising' in recent years because of losses, high inflation and
a government that siphons off funds from it. Most of its 200-300
offices don't open, its workforce is poorly trained and motivated, and
it is greatly inhibited by government regulation over interest rates
and the like. Meanwhile, private banks (most of which scarcely
function themselves) are forbidden from lending to cultivators."

Even the PONJA – the Post Nargis Joint Assessment written jointly by
the government, the UN and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations
(ASEAN) recognizes farmers complaints about the quality of the seeds
they have been loaned by the bank – inadequate for planting. It also
states that the loaned machinery often doesn't work or farmers don't
know how to use it. INGO's are reluctant to comment specifically on
the MADB.

PONJA says of the government loans; They were "in general too small,
inadequate to cover the working capital for paddy productions." It
goes on to say that this has meant farmers "have taken substantial
loans from private money-holders."

The loans are taken with an expectation for a monsoon paddy harvest
this October, or sometimes by workers on their as yet, unearned future
expected pay - this is often below market rate. Dr Sean Turnell points
out two repercussions to this irregular debt spiral: "Firstly, the
high interest rates levied by moneylenders adds to the poverty of
borrowers," he says, "secondly, it raises the spectre of collateral
seizure in the event of default."

Seizure of unproductive land is a worry expressed in PONJA. Yet again
small farmers in the delta region are particularly vulnerable. Under
Myanmar law farmers risk losing the right to farm their land if they
have an unproductive year.

In the delta informal moneylenders are often larger farmers, who may
be within their rights to seize smaller farmer's land if loans are not
repaid.

In the Delta now there are reports that the interest rate for informal
money lending has stayed lower than pre-cyclone days at about 10-20
percent per month - which still compounds the longer the loan is
extended beyond the first month. Informal interest rates are often
three or four times that of a government-registered pawnshop of ten
percent per month. Informal money lending rates of 200 percent over a
year are not unusual.

But most importantly the rate is not standard but adjusts to the
individual relationship of lender to borrower. "The arrangement is
often an intimate one, between family or neighbours who understand the
circumstances for the loan," says Khin Maung Nyo. It allows
flexibility, but also risks exploitation.

The lack of adequate banking and loan facilities is one of the reasons
that the United Nation's Development Program (UNDP) has run a
microfinance project in Myanmar since 2004. They have given loans
amounting to US$23 million to over 80,000 borrowers, mainly women
throughout the Ayeryarwady delta.

They argue that although a cycle of debt and poverty can be
detrimental to long-term development, it is the circumstances of those
loans as opposed to the lending itself that can be so destructive.
Microfinance aims to create a culture of responsibility and business
entrepreneurs, says Sanaka Samarasinha, deputy resident representative
for UNDP. The micro-finance program offers loans from 60 or 70,000
kyat to five hundred dollars to borrowers. "One or two hundred dollars
is about average," says Mr Samarasinha, "We also offer special loans
for education or for health."

"The repayment rate is incredibly high – over 90 percent," explains Mr
Samarasinha. "Some invest in livestock – others set up shops. Along
with the access to credit – we provide them with some guidance on how
to manage business." Those considered the most vulnerable households
tend to migrate and follow their work. These are the people whose
needs it is hardest for the program to meet, as meetings and
monitoring are an essential part of the microfinance program, says Mr
Samarasinna.

The cyclone has had a major impact on the UNDP program itself, which
is at present calling for funding of $US2.7 million to cover
refinancing loans and paying back savings that were lost. $951,000 of
this would cover such loans. This would also expand the microfinance
program to cover a further 38,000 people (putting the program at
100,000 recipients). The Self Reliance Groups (a program which also
offers loans to community groups) lost k901 million to Nargis. 859
members of self-reliance groups were killed. All of them were women.

"Many of the villages we've been to have said they want microfinance
to re-start," says Mr Samarasinha "they have also said - that they can
and will pay back the loans – but they need more time. They might also
be willing to pay back their original loan – if they can then access a
larger loan."
"This speaks to the fact that people have become conditioned that this
is not money for nothing – not free money – but that there is a
responsibility that comes with access to credit," he says.

But despite planning to re-start and extend its microfinance program
in the delta and Yangon division, so far the program has been
suspended, as they try to offer other forms of assistance.

Mr Samarasinha also admits that microfinance has its limitations, "it
is only one part of development," he says, "Considering that there are
a lot of people who fell down a [poverty] bracket or two – there may
be people who are not in a position to access micro-finance right now,
for whom grants might be better."

Dr Turnell agrees: "Microfinance can play an important part in
reconstruction, but it cannot be the full answer," he says,
"Microfinance can't really provide larger scale and longer term
lending for capital investment, reconstruction of farms and the like –
nor can they really provide seasonal crop loans of the sort
cultivators need. For this, [the country] needs properly functioning
financial institutions."

In the absence of private banks and a proper financial system the
survivors of cyclone Nargis have few options. As the mounds of items
pile up in the pawnshops in Yangon and the delta they are a visible
reminder of the difficult times Myanmar faces today. In October, if -
as is likely - the harvest fails the weight of this debt will only
become heavier.

1 Comments:

Blogger Selmo said...

What a very different picture you give to a recent BBC article:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7699615.stm

It's good to get insider info, thank you!

8:15 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home