Beckilina

Sunday, August 29, 2010

Forgiving ourselves

I am stood on top of this white lorry on my final day in Kakuma. From this point we can see Kakuma 3 spreading out around us, in a dusty, dirty, sun-set infused beauty. There are children everywhere -screaming, racing, running - like crazed spinning tops set lose. They are waiting for the evening screening to begin and have raced behind the Film Aid lorry all the way through the spindly roads to this clearing. Staff from my NGO are rolling out a rope behind which the children know they must sit. One of my students tells me she was one of those children a few years ago. She never believed one day she would make a film to be screened to the others. We are laughing and dancing and smiling on the top of our lorry - unfurling a giant white screen on
which our films will be projected. The rubbish dump to our left and the tarpaulin houses are bathed in golden light.

We have not stopped editing for days now and we are high from four nights of two hours of sleep. Daytimes spent crammed into a darkened sauna of an office, trying to teach seven of the students how to use professional editing software. Night-times spent drinking illuminous green and orange sodas and undoing the mistakes the students have made during the day. It is like Rupelstilskin backwards. I thank my lucky stars that one of the incentive workers from the NGO is so damn good at editing and that I have managed to recruit a Canadian communications PHD student to help with the editing. The three of us, our eyes blinking back the tears of tiredness click through edits as 4 am slips ever closer and our creativity slips further away. Each morning I try to come up with a schedule for the other 23 students. I set them film scavenger hunts and interview assignments and hope the two refugees I've been training as facilitators can control the energy and pandemonium that often set in.

So far, our teams have been arrested, taken into custody by WFP, slapped across the face by their interviewees and been attacked by the host population. Each time an "incident" takes place I sit the team down, buy them chai and try to figure out how we can prevent this in the future. The next day an entirely different "incident" occurs. Part of it is the topics they've chosen - asking people about survival sex is provocative at the best of times. When you are also carrying a camera it can be seen as positively aggressive. And for all the hours I've spent trying to help with "rehearsing" the best approach - there comes a point when they're on their own and the co-facilitators I've been trying to train find it hard to pull back on the enthusiasm of the group.

But we have come helterskeltering to this final evening and the tape is recorded, the edits roughly finished and tomorrow I will be in an armed convoy to the border and on a UN flight back to Nairobi.

There's been so little time for reflection and thought. The daily evaluations I have enshrined into the facilitators' day have become more and more brief as the anxiety of producing four documentaries has consumed our world. But now, standing on this lorry, utterly absorbed in how much I love this camp and these young people and the great privilege of being here this summer, another lesson in perspective slaps me in the face.

She is 19 years old.

She's hardened in the way almost all my female students are: A teenager with a 9 month old baby. She pulled herself through childhood without parents. She wears her hair braided and her luminous clothes and provocative dancing tell the story of learning to make ends meet. Rejected from her community I had spoken with her earlier in the week about some problems she was facing. Housing seems a problem for all of my students - the majority of them are unaccompanied and live on the kindness of others. For all the amazing camaraderie between people not related by blood, the fact that families take in orphans creates problems. Whenever there are fights, or disagreements, my students are thrown out of their homes and end up with nowhere to live.

She argued with the woman she was living with on the Monday of editing week. She'd gone to an NGO that's supposed to help vulnerable women and had boasted to us about getting women out of sex work in an interview last week. The NGO offered her free hand cream.

On the Tuesday she tried to hang herself.

That Friday she and I sat on top of the lorry, waiting for the films to start. She told me about her suicide attempt. I blundered through a whole range of cliches about living for her daughter. And I wondered why on earth I had sat in a darkened office the last four days editing films when I should have been pushing for housing solutions for her.

Eight hours later I was crying in the back of an IOM car desperately trying to persuade an IOM councillor to follow up on all my students.

It's never enough.

So yet again I have left, with threads tangled. My students are I are facebook friends. They use friend's phones to reply to my ever more urgent messages, as I phone and leave messages for child protection in Kakuma and they continue to ignore me.

I try desperately to figure out a way of sending 1000 dollars to Kenya to support another Sudanese girl to go to boarding school, and find that sending money is hopelessly difficult - and wonder if I can justify sending one girl to school, when giving to an NGO might have a greater impact on policy.

The process of choosing who to help is heart-breakingly and frighteningly arbitrary. I could change one student's life, thanks to one conversation we had, once, on a dusty hill overlooking the camp. And why should I choose her over any one of the
other 30, who are all equally deserving...

We get tangled up - wrapped into the human desire to connect and the weird power dynamic of aid, that skews friendships and basic human interaction.

It was easier to be a journalist. Easier to write articles, or create videos or photographs - to witness injustice and hope by writing something, someone would do something to stop it. There are lines in journalism - professional constraints that mean you focus on the individual as a way of changing the more abstract notions of responsibility. We offer people a voice (or idealistically that is what I hope we do). In some ways this project this summer was an extension of that - a belief that people can tell their own stories - but in other ways I know I didn't interact with these students as a journalist - we played theater games and blew vuvuzelas and ate cabbage and rice every day and danced to Tanzanian pop songs and talked about love and
figured out how we were going to make four films together. And while for 6 weeks or so we were - as far as it is possible to be - equals, on that Saturday morning, as I waved goodbye to those 30 young people, all pretensions of equality fell away.

I don't know how you ever leave. I don't know how you ever balance the desire to help the individuals you meet with the need
to alter the structures that place so many in such black holes.

I sit in classes in Berkeley and it all feels so indulgent and luxurious. I know we must learn to go back and forth between these
great chasms that divide the world. I believe to do so is the beginning of understanding and sharing that understanding, which is the only place from which we can stand in solidarity. I believe we SHOULD be horrified by the disparity and appalled that
Berkeley can exist alongside Kakuma - but I think it breaks us too.

How can it not?

It makes me think of a quote I read once - "Let sorrowful longing dwell in your heart. Never give up, never lose hope. Allah says "the broken ones are my beloved." Crush your heart. Be broken" - Shaikh Abu Saeed Abil Kheir, aka Nobody, son of Nobody.

Perhaps all these breaks teach us compassion. Perhaps these cracks make us who we are. Perhaps we must know the sadness of the world in order to believe that it cannot continue in the way it is - I'm sure there are any number of beautiful phrases and quotes to turn all this guilt and loss and disgust into something that sounds beautiful. But somehow, that doesn't help so much right now. Because right now all I can think about is my students and how they have grown up hardened to the world. Disbelieving of those that try to help them: Untrusting of the aid agencies, of their parents, of their governments, of their communities to protect them. And now, I am also a part of that cycle - yet another reason to rely entirely on themselves - and to keep their stories and their struggles to themselves - in short, to lose faith in people. And I wonder if the greatest lesson we must learn from all this sadness is how we learn to forgive ourselves when time after time we are just not enough and fail so completely to offer protection to those who deserve it.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home