Beckilina

Wednesday, August 17, 2005

Another Georgian character

Tomorrow I am set to bump into Cedric – my French/UN writer on my way to work – he will convince me (it will not take long) to go drink Turkish coffees as he smokes endless cigarettes and talks about his research for his book and his pessimism for Georgia instead of going to work. So we will go sit in a dark smoky red café on Rustaveli until 3 o’clock. We will sigh over Europe, laugh because numerous waiters will bring the wrong food, the wrong coffee, the wrong bill – and then take it away as we are in the midst of eating it to replace it with some other random dish. We will argue because Cedric believes women shouldn’t pay the bill (being a feminist doesn’t seem to help) and finally he will win and I will hold my money out to no avail. At last we will part ways and I will wander past the street booksellers, the sesame seed traders, the green of the trees, the numerous blue clad police officers in the brightest sunshine back to work and promise myself that I will stay late to make up for my lazy morning.

I will wonder if Cedric has just spent too long in Tbilisi or been heartbroken by too many Georgian women and then I will just wish that I understood Georgia better so that I could argue that Georgians are not fundamentally ‘backward’ 'peasants' 'farmers' 'uncivilised'– I will groan because I hate the connotations of superiority that come with those words and because I don’t believe the ‘feudalism’ of Georgia and its inability to protect itself, to embrace capitalism, to embrace the outside world as a whole is a sign that Georgia will not have democracy. I will feel repulsed by the idea of categorising an entire nation and predicting their future on their past – and yet I will feel unable to completely disqualify what Cedric has said – or what hundreds of thousands of years of different influences, cultures, religious and moral understandings does to a people. Still, Cedric can't seem to get away from some quiet infatuation with the bright lights of civilisation and democracy that apparently beam from France and Briitain And who am I to say that Georgia can exist as a state in the same way that France or Britain does?

I will wonder if it is true that the Georgian church was selling slaves and concubines for almost all of its existence, that it is a den of thieves and criminals who foster the shallow idea of Christianity without infusing any of the moral code that accompany it. I will find myself questioning the development of Europe verses the Caucasus. I will wonder if it’s true that Georgia would have been destroyed and conquered as a nation if its geopolitical situation hadn’t allowed the crusades to distract the attention of the Middle Eastern powers southwards. I will wonder if it is true that Russia brought civilisation to Georgia – and its strength was reliant only on that external power – not on the internal structures and mentalities. I will wonder if Georgia’s existence will really be swamped and swallowed up by Russia again. I will wonder if it’s true that Georgians are just ‘incapable of protecting their boundaries’ or building capitalism or making businesses work. I will wonder why Georgia is becoming more closed off to the world and not more open – I will wonder if that is even true – or if the mentality that exists here is far more Asian than it is European. Lunch with my dear French friend with his blue shirts and tinted glasses always leaves me slightly disgruntled, my feathers slightly ruffled – despite his disillusionment with Georgia he can't quite get away from the fact that he's crazily madly infatuated by the country, its people and its history. Still, I will probably not feel entirely at ease again until the next time I speak with an NGO or a UN agency that is actually doing some blatant good here.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home