Shades of Myanmar in Haiti
For many the world turned upside down in Haiti on January 12th 2010. For me it was in Myanmar, May 2 2008.
Cyclone Nargis became the pivot around which everything I knew was measured, a twisting, earth crunching moment. And everything else fell away in gaping holes to either side of it.
Natural disasters change millions of people’s lives. They also, in my experience, present an opportunity for attacking the severe poverty in the country involved. Yet without long-term and well-funded efforts, the space offered by disasters closes quickly and the opportunities, just like the TV cameras and the world’s attention and money, moves on.
My notes from the time don’t articulate it like that. They are a record of numbers. The event "Nargis" short-handed to N, the world neatly broken into Before N (BN) and After N (AN).
There were 511 people in this village BN, now there are 224 AN.
As if numbers and scrawled notes could help me understand a village where most of the women and children were dead. We now know 180,000 people were lost in the twelve hours that it took Nargis to surge in from the Bay of Bengal and across the south of Myanmar, a toll strikingly similar to the current estimates for Haiti.
But I’m leaping ahead. Numbers come later.
In Yangon that May, what came first was a blackout. By 10pm the rains picked up and a muggy wind of foreboding began banging doors shut.
Part of our roof was wrenched off and some of the windows sucked out as Nargis got going. It sounded like a giant was throwing glass bottles against the walls of our house over and over again. But our brick house was lucky.
In the suburbs unpaved roads wash out every monsoon season, electricity is rare and education just like health a luxury. The shacks of the poor gave little protection. Recognizing their way by touch and instinct they left their homes in search of safety, hanging onto their children, terrified of losing them to the wind, or the corrugated iron roofs that flew like razor blades through the air.
Hundreds of thousands waited in the pitch-black, hoping for the sun to rise and put some shapes to the sounds of tearing metal that screeched through the night. Time was not a logical force. We must have stayed that way for hours, until dawn bled into the sky and the eye of the storm passed over Yangon. A disconcerting calm settled. I caught a glimpse of an a hundred-year old tree that had been ripped up by the roots, before Nargis engulfed us again.
What had been frightening in Yangon had been deadly in the Irrawaddy delta, where a tidal surge, in some places measuring 15 foot, had accompanied the 190 mile/hour winds.
Red robed monks hacked at 30-foot trees with pocketknives. The coconut trees were often all that had survived – they had bent with the wind instead of snapping. When one person after another showed me their chests, raw from hours of clinging to those trees I realized that it was how many people had survived. It was also how stories began.
“My wife and my two sons and I – we hung on for hours at the top of that tree,” one rice farmer told me as he pointed out the battered branches. His skin had gathered in folds under his eyes from lack of sleep. Like almost everyone in the delta he had had no radio to hear a cyclone warning, even if there had been one. “I was holding onto the family. Grasping them. But, the water was there for hours and I knew I would fall, it was black – I couldn’t see anything.”
And then?
“I had to let them go,” he said. “One after the other.”
His haunted eyes were so similar to those looking into the cameras in Port-au-Prince.
As in Haiti last month, the authorities in Yangon were not out on the streets those first days. Unlike Haiti however, the Burmese government kept foreign aid workers out for the first three weeks following the crisis.
It wasn’t until a visit from the head of the United Nations that aid workers were allowed visas and the humanitarian aid effort began in earnest. There was unprecedented access to the Irrawaddy delta. Spontaneous civil society groups sprang up to bring rice to the delta. The world gave money to a country that until then, because of the reputation of its government, had got the least amount of humanitarian funding per person out of all the least developed countries – just $4 per person in 2007, compared to $47 in neighboring Cambodia.
Nargis showed that despite the government’s reputation, humanitarian work is possible in Myanmar. But radios, paved roads and solid buildings are still few and far between: many homes have still not been rebuilt. The United Nations is desperate for money to help with long-term recovery and the government is slowing down visas and permits for foreign aid workers.
Overcoming the poverty that left so many people vulnerable to Nargis requires still more and it is not enough to wait for an emergency before we address it.
In Haiti, where government restrictions are not an issue, the opportunity is greater. It is even more important then that the world stays committed to long-term development, even after the next disaster has the limelight.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home